FIELD NOTES / BIOINFORMATICS DISCOVERY LOOP

Finding a contribution in biology + computing

Find and execute a valuable, plausibly original research contribution using public data and programming. Interests: genetics, plant design, birds and birdwatching. Failed and overlapping ideas remain visible.

Round 4 running: birds only, no BirdNET. Three completed studies preserved.

Started 2026-09-19 · Updated 2026-09-19 06:51 UTC

What counts as success

Read study 4: training reuse in a great tit developmental clock

ATTEMPT 001

Are source recordings independent in a nocturnal bird-call benchmark?

Closed — no direct train/test overlap detected

Question

Do publicly identifiable shared source recordings cross the NBM train/test split, and could this invalidate an otherwise independent comparison?

Why it might matter

A direct audit is cheap and could yield a useful correction if genuine overlap exists. The authors already address sampling bias and deliberately select later uploads for testing, so general concerns about leakage are not new.

Minimal test

Retrieve metadata; compare recording identifiers, filenames, source origin and available contributor/session fields. If no direct overlap is found, reject this narrow lead unless independent evidence supports audio duplication.

First novelty check

Initial reading: source paper explicitly discusses class imbalance, contributor imbalance, train/test upload-date separation, possible BirdNET pretraining overlap, and focal-versus-passive domain shift. These are established issues, not our contributions.

Decision and next step

Reject the narrow direct-leakage hypothesis. This test cannot exclude cropped, re-encoded or same-session recordings; no broad claim of independence is made.

Observed results

Evidence and outputs

Sources and closest prior work

Exact literature search queries
  • "Nocturnal Bird Migration" dataset leakage duplicates evaluation
  • "NBM" "Airale" dataset bias annotation
ATTEMPT 002

Can duplicate audio reveal annotation uncertainty?

Closed — annotation provenance insufficient

Question

Can multiple annotations of repeated NBM audio quantify uncertainty in detection benchmarks?

Why it might matter

The directory audit exposed repeated audio candidates with differently named annotation files.

Minimal test

Read the annotation files of all ten candidate groups and distinguish mere formatting, revised labels, missing files and independently drawn boundaries.

First novelty check

Inter-annotator agreement and boundary uncertainty in bioacoustics are already established topics. Accidental repeated files would only support a new result if their annotation provenance and independence were known.

Limitations

No annotator identity or independent repeated-labeling design is provided. CRC identity is only a screen. Ten convenience-sampled groups cannot represent the full dataset.

Decision and next step

Retain as a limited data-quality finding. No general uncertainty estimate and no novelty claim. Large WAV pairs were not downloaded merely to confirm this unsuitable lead.

Observed results

Evidence and outputs

Sources and closest prior work

Exact literature search queries
  • bioacoustic bounding box annotation inter annotator IoU repeatability bird detection
  • "NBM" "duplicate" birds dataset
  • "bioacoustic" "inter-annotator" bounding boxes
ATTEMPT 003

Does changing song-versus-call composition distort automated activity estimates?

Closed — pilot failed advancement gates

Question

Within the same bird species and soundscape, does BirdNET recall differ between songs and contact calls enough to distort activity estimates when their mixture changes?

Why it might matter

A detector can recognize a species well overall yet undersample one behavior. A useful contribution would quantify the within-species, within-recording effect across many species and determine how much duration/context explains it.

Minimal test

Use the new CEB soundscape annotations to count species with both songs and contact calls. Run a frozen BirdNET v2.4 model on a bounded stratified sample of eligible three-second windows, with no geographic prior. Compare per-species recall at fixed thresholds 0.1 and 0.5. Exclude windows containing both song and contact-call annotations of the focal species. Frozen implementation: SHA256 seed 20260919 assigns whole files to pilot (hash mod 3 == 0) or validation. Keep species with at least three paired files overall and at least one in each phase; at most three pilot files/species. Select one window per behavior/species/file using event-ID hashes. Exclude other annotated behaviors of the focal species from each window. No padding; source windows remain inside the three-minute file. Primary threshold 0.1; 0.5 is sensitivity only. These paired source files are not independent identified birds.

First novelty check

Broad call-type evaluation is not new: Weldy et al. (2025) compare sonotypes, and call-type classifiers exist. The narrower candidate is a comparative, same-recording audit of behavior-mixture bias and a practical calibration/abstention diagnostic. Need determine whether this distinction is substantive after the pilot. Clapp et al. (2026) explicitly identify time-varying recall as an open gap while studying precision; a 2022 researcher discussion already connects song/call mixtures to phenology. The broad problem is established. Our possible contribution is empirical estimation and validation of within-recording behavior-specific recall, not originating the concern.

Larger test / frozen decision gates

Advance only if at least ten species have usable paired data and the median species-level recall gap is at least 0.15 at a prespecified threshold. Larger validation must use disjoint recording groups, resample species and recordings rather than calls, examine duration/context and source effects, and seek external replication. Do not call a threshold-free score difference a recall effect.

Limitations

No seasonal or population-abundance inference is available from these labels alone. CEB test data are a convenience sample; independence from original BirdNET training needs verification. Annotation type is expert-assigned behavior, not individual sex/age.

Decision and next step

Do not advance to validation or claim a general song advantage. Held-out recordings have not been scored. A future substantially different hypothesis must be logged explicitly and cannot reuse these pilot results as confirmation.

Observed results

Evidence and outputs

Sources and closest prior work

Exact literature search queries
  • BirdNET accuracy "begging" calls song
  • BirdNET vocalization type performance call song bias evaluation
  • "BirdNET" "vocalization type" performance bias phenology
  • "Central European Birds" vocalization types benchmark
  • "BirdNET" "songs and calls" "recall"
  • "BirdNET" "song" "contact call" performance
  • "Passive Acoustic Data as Phenological Distributions" data call song
ATTEMPT 004

Do bird mitochondrial coding annotations reproduce their deposited proteins?

Closed — control passes; closely covered by prior work

Question

Can a small annotation audit distinguish legitimate mitochondrial recoding from incorrect coding annotations in public bird genomes?

Why it might matter

Bird mitochondrial ND3 sometimes contains an extra nucleotide handled by recoding. Incorrect treatment can create misleading proteins in comparative analyses. A useful project would need a specific new failure mode beyond established mitogenome quality audits.

Minimal test

Download a well-characterized chicken mitogenome from ENA. Parse CDS features, translation tables and exceptions; compare extracted coding sequences to deposited protein translations. Distinguish incomplete terminal stops and programmed frameshifts from defects.

First novelty check

Andreu-Sánchez et al. (2021) analyzed tens of thousands of ND3 sequences, including recoding-site evolution and annotation issues. Sangster & Luksenburg (2021) systematically investigated avian mitogenome errors and downstream reuse. This proposed general audit lacks a sufficiently distinct question.

Decision and next step

Stop this candidate after the control and first novelty check; do not perform a larger scan merely to rediscover known problems.

Observed results

Evidence and outputs

Sources and closest prior work

Exact literature search queries
  • avian mitochondrial genome ND3 frameshift annotation errors 2024 2025 2026
  • "Sharp Increase of Problematic Mitogenomes" data github
ATTEMPT 005

Can seasonal species filters censor early migrants?

Closed — direct prior study found

Question

Does a date-dependent species allowlist introduce an artificial detection boundary for early or late migrating birds even when the acoustic evidence is unchanged?

Why it might matter

A seasonal prior can improve identification, but phenology studies target deviations from expected timing. A substantive contribution would quantify documented true-positive losses and resulting timing bias, beyond the familiar warning that priors can miss rare birds.

Minimal test

Run the official BirdNET v2.4 geographic model at a fixed European location for all 48 modeled weeks. Record default-threshold allowlist crossings for common migratory birds and compare with the year-round mode. This is a counterfactual model diagnostic, not evidence that a bird was present on any particular date.

First novelty check

A June 2026 preprint by Pérez-Granados et al. directly compares no filter, spatial filter and spatiotemporal filter across worldwide annotated soundscapes. Its discussion specifically warns about missing early and late migrants. This materially overlaps the question.

Larger test / frozen decision gates

Only advance if meaningful week-dependent exclusions occur and the exact research question is not already answered. Larger validation needs dated, geolocated, independently annotated recordings and must distinguish removing false positives from losing genuine early/late detections. Model-only calendar curves cannot establish real ecological bias.

Decision and next step

Reject the broad seasonal-censoring study as insufficiently new; no expensive soundscape analysis.

Observed results

Evidence and outputs

Sources and closest prior work

Exact literature search queries
  • BirdNET seasonal geographic filter early arrival phenology bias
  • BirdNET range filter climate change migration detection prior circularity
  • "BirdNET" "week" "bias" phenology
ATTEMPT 006

Is a year-round species list guaranteed to contain every weekly list?

Closed — related behavior already documented; small pilot anomaly

Question

Does the BirdNET year-round filter obey the expected nesting of all weekly allowlists?

Why it might matter

A year-round filter is trained to predict peak weekly occurrence, yet unconstrained neural predictions might violate that relationship. This would be a sharper question than the seasonal-filter warning.

Minimal test

Compare official week=-1 outputs with the maximum of weeks 1–48 at five fixed locations, using the default 0.03 cutoff.

First novelty check

BirdNET-Analyzer issue #211 already reports year-round lists differing from the union of weekly lists. The maintainer explains that the -1 mode is trained separately against maximum weekly checklist frequencies. Our reverse-direction exceptions are a narrow consequence of the same unconstrained approximation; no material ecological impact has been established.

Limitations

Five model coordinates, no independently confirmed bird occurrences, and two small cutoff crossings. No evidence of missed real recordings or precision improvement from a proposed fix.

Decision and next step

Retain the reproducible observation but do not call it a new research contribution or enlarge it solely to accumulate discrepancies.

Observed results

Evidence and outputs

Sources and closest prior work

Exact literature search queries
  • "BirdNET" "year-round" "maximum"
  • "BirdNET" "year-round" "missing" species
  • "BirdNET" "species lists" "nested"
  • GitHub issues search: repo:birdnet-team/BirdNET-Analyzer "year round"
ATTEMPT 007

Do plant promoter benchmarks separate independent DNA sequences?

Closed — exact overlap too small to support lead

Question

Do public plant promoter benchmarks contain exact or reverse-complement-identical sequences across train/test splits, or duplicated parent constructs that permit target memorization?

Why it might matter

Plant design increasingly depends on sequence-to-function models. A concrete, consequential benchmark flaw could be valuable to document, but generic concerns about genomic train/test leakage are established and do not themselves constitute novelty.

Minimal test

Download the public PDLLMs core-promoter classification splits and the PGB tobacco-leaf promoter-strength splits. Audit exact sequences, reverse complements, duplicated labels and available sequence IDs. If there is a material overlap, test a training-only lookup baseline before any expensive model training.

First novelty check

Initial source reading: AgroNT uses held-out chromosomes for several genomic tasks and adopts the published Jores promoter-strength splits. Respect each benchmark’s intended generalization target; related sequences alone are not proof of inappropriate leakage. Generic homology-induced evaluation leakage is studied directly by Rafi et al. (2025 preprint). The original Jores study explicitly used random promoter holdouts; finding related promoters would not alone contradict that design.

Larger test / frozen decision gates

Advance only if an overlap or shortcut has a measurable predictive consequence and contradicts a stated evaluation target; require new holdouts or group-aware splits and re-check whether the specific issue has already been reported.

Limitations

Reverse-complement identity does not guarantee the same directional promoter function. Exact overlap counts alone are not a measure of model optimism.

Decision and next step

Close this narrow exact-overlap hypothesis. No substantive overall evaluation effect is established. Homology and nearest-neighbor leakage require a different analysis; absence of exact copies does not exclude them.

Observed results

Evidence and outputs

Sources and closest prior work

Exact literature search queries
  • plant genomic benchmark sequence data leakage AgroNT PlantCaduceus 2026
  • "AgroNT" "leakage"
  • "plant-genomic-benchmark" "duplicate"
  • "plant-multi-species-core-promoters" leakage
  • "PDLLMs" leakage duplicate benchmark
ATTEMPT 008

Does arbitrary window alignment change recognition of a complete short bird call?

Closed — established overlap/context problem

Question

How sensitive are BirdNET scores to temporal translation of a short vocalization that remains fully inside its three-second input?

Why it might matter

If small changes in the analysis grid alter complete-event detection, comparing counts from differently aligned files can add avoidable uncertainty. A new contribution would need a measured practical consequence and a validated correction beyond standard overlapping windows.

Minimal test

Reuse the previously frozen pilot sample, selecting only events at most 1.2 seconds long. Circularly shift each identical three-second waveform by −0.6, −0.3, 0, +0.3 and +0.6 seconds. The centered target event remains intact. Also shift real source-window starts by those offsets. Compare threshold-crossing fractions at 0.1 (primary) and 0.5 (secondary). Advance to novelty review if at least 20% of eligible events cross 0.1 across shifts.

First novelty check

Prior BirdNET/Chirpity implementations already address segmentation-dependent false positives through overlapping-window consensus. Translation sensitivity of CNNs and bird-audio window-size effects are established. Need a distinct practical contribution before larger validation. The 2024 Chirpity discussion describes the boundary-confusion mechanism and an implemented adjacent-window rule; the global BirdNET assessment cites tests of overlap and vocalization duration. Our observations are too close to these established concerns.

Limitations

Circular shifts can cut background events and create a boundary seam. Real source shifts change contextual audio. These are diagnostics, not yet a pure causal attribution or field error rate; pilot selection is inherited from an earlier question.

Decision and next step

Do not enlarge this generic translation diagnostic. The known overlap/consensus approaches already address the practical concern, and our pilot cannot isolate a new failure mechanism. Preserve scores and move to a different question.

Observed results

Evidence and outputs

Sources and closest prior work

Exact literature search queries
  • BirdNET "time shift" prediction
  • BirdNET "window" "position" detection confidence overlap
  • bird sound classification temporal translation invariance window alignment
ATTEMPT 009

How reliable are the expression targets in plant promoter benchmarks?

Closed broad noise question — follow-up on coding barcodes

Question

Do low-precision expression measurements change evaluation or design rankings in reused plant promoter benchmarks?

Why it might matter

Repeated floating-point target values in the downloaded promoter data motivate checking their experimental origin. Count-based reporter measurements have unequal precision; a useful study would connect that uncertainty to design decisions or model evaluation, beyond merely observing measurement noise.

Minimal test

Read original measurement-processing code and compare benchmark labels with source measurements and biological replicates. First determine whether repeated labels reflect low counts, normalization or something else; do not infer low coverage from ties alone. Quantify replicate disagreement across a fixed Arabidopsis leaf pilot before selecting a larger test.

First novelty check

Heteroscedastic MPRA measurements, count-ratio bias and barcode-related uncertainty are established. MTSA (Lee et al., 2021) directly models sequence-specific barcode effects. The source study already reports replicate correlations. No general novelty claim from re-quantifying these facts.

Limitations

Noise-aware MPRA analysis already exists. Novelty would require a distinct demonstrated consequence in plant design benchmarks. Expression differences between leaf and protoplast assays confound species, tissue and assay system.

Decision and next step

Do not claim generic measurement-noise discovery. The source construct places a 12-base random barcode in the first four codons after the initiation codon, motivating a separate specific hypothesis about positional barcode sequence effects.

Observed results

Evidence and outputs

Sources and closest prior work

Exact literature search queries
  • "plant" "promoter" "benchmark" "measurement noise"
  • "Jores" "promoter" "low" "counts"
ATTEMPT 010

Do short coding barcodes systematically alter plant promoter readouts?

Closed — below frozen pilot thresholds

Question

In Plant STARR-seq, does the identity and position of bases in a four-codon barcode predict RNA/DNA enrichment among barcodes attached to the same promoter?

Why it might matter

The barcode follows the start codon rather than lying in a 3′ UTR. A position-specific, reproducible effect could implicate assay architecture and guide barcode design. We cannot infer a translation or RNA-decay mechanism solely from count associations.

Minimal test

Use Arabidopsis library, tobacco leaf, enhancer present, dark, replicate 1. Reproduce original RNA/DNA count cutoff ≥5 and WT/full-length mapping filter. Fit within-promoter effects of one-hot bases at all 12 barcode positions, holding out complete promoter groups by fixed SHA256 hash. Compare held-out residual prediction with zero. Advance if held-out R² is at least 0.01 or the fitted first-barcode-base contrast spans at least 0.1 log2 units; validate in an independent biological replicate and another assay system if novelty survives.

First novelty check

General sequence-specific barcode bias and correction are known from MTSA. The candidate is the specific positional behavior of short translated barcodes in plant assays and its reproducible practical impact. This distinction must be tested against the full prior literature, not inferred from the different organism alone.

Limitations

Original count truncation, promoter sequence variants, barcode misassignment and sequence-dependent sequencing/RT efficiencies are alternative explanations. Shared barcodes across replicates are not independent randomized interventions. Source code clarifies that the metadata mutations field lists intentional restriction-site-removal edits, while variant=WT identifies a match to the designed construct; nonempty mutations is not evidence of sequencing error.

Decision and next step

Do not enlarge the study by adjusting the gate after seeing a near miss. Small sequence effects may exist, but this pilot does not establish a practically consequential new bias or a translation mechanism.

Observed results

Evidence and outputs

Sources and closest prior work

Exact literature search queries
  • plant STARR seq barcode sequence bias promoter Jores
  • "barcode" "sequence" "bias" MPRA RNA stability
ATTEMPT 011

Are bird-audio predictions invariant to computational batching?

Closed — batching invariance passes

Question

Does an identical waveform receive materially different BirdNET scores when batched with silence, a different recording, or an amplified recording?

Why it might matter

Batching should alter throughput, not the meaning of individual samples. A failure could reveal an actionable normalization issue rather than a generic ecological limitation.

Minimal test

Check dynamic-batch support in the frozen official TFLite model. Compare identical waveform logits alone and in batches of two with zero, independent and 10×-amplitude distractors. A material failure requires a score difference greater than 0.01 or a change at score threshold 0.1, beyond numerical roundoff.

Limitations

This tests one frozen acoustic model and inference backend. It is not a comparison of model versions or a biological effect.

Decision and next step

Reject the batch-dependence hypothesis for this model/backend. No reason for a larger experiment.

Observed results

Evidence and outputs

Sources and closest prior work

Exact literature search queries
ATTEMPT 012

Does barcode count filtering make promoter ranks depend on sequencing depth?

Executed — validated resource-specific robustness result

Question

When the same RNA count table is computationally thinned, does the published per-barcode RNA≥5 filter and median-ratio estimator systematically change promoter rankings?

Why it might matter

This is a specific ascertainment question prompted by source-code inspection, distinct from ordinary replicate noise. Low-RNA barcodes disappear as depth falls; a retained-only median may shift as the surviving barcode set changes. A useful contribution requires a material and avoidable effect on current plant-design benchmark targets.

Minimal test

Use Arabidopsis leaf replicate 1 raw counts. Keep the original WT/full-length associations and original DNA≥5 rule. Compare full counts with seeded binomial RNA thinning to 50% and 25%; recompute the original median of retained log2 RNA/DNA ratios and correct the known dilution. Contrast with a fixed-barcode pooled-count ratio retaining RNA zeros. Analyze common promoters with ≥10 DNA-supported barcodes, report retention and all rank shifts. Advance only if median absolute activity shift exceeds 0.25 log2 units or rank correlation drops below 0.95 at 25% depth.

First novelty check

mpralm (2019) derives lower bias for aggregate ratios than mean log ratios; a 2025 human-assay comparison recommends DNA-based filtering. These establish the statistical rationale. Searches so far did not locate a direct depth-intervention audit of the Jores/PGB plant promoter targets. This is provisional novelty of an empirical benchmark consequence, not a new estimator.

Larger test / frozen decision gates

Before inspecting further outcomes: reconstruct normalized original labels exactly using barcode controls and two-replicate means; verify against deposited source data. Validate with At leaf replicate 2 and Zm leaf replicate 1, with Zm leaf replicate 2 for complete benchmark reproduction. Use five seeded thinnings at 50% and 25% RNA depth. Compare retained median, all-barcode median with 0.5 pseudocount, retained pooled counts and all-barcode pooled counts. Primary identical promoter set: >=10 DNA-supported barcodes, full-depth observed in all methods, and retained in the thin original estimator; separately report dropout. Preserve source cutoff DNA>=5; sensitivity DNA>=20. Advancement requires original-estimator quarter-depth Spearman<0.95 in both new validation libraries and pooled-all improvement >=0.05; test pooled-retained to isolate censorship from aggregation. Evaluate actual independent-replicate agreement before recommending any corrected label set. Seek published-model consequences using original held-out predictions. Clarification before validation outcomes: exact historical reconstruction is established by attempt 013; depth tests use robust whitespace counts and independently reconstructed corrected values. PGB targets are a distinct snapshot and cannot yet be called corrected by these values.

Second novelty check

MPRAsnakeflow (2025) already evaluates count/barcode downsampling and replicate agreement in human libraries. mpralm (2019) already explains advantages of pooling counts. A general downsampling tool or new pooling estimator would not be novel. The remaining contribution is a reproducible, resource-specific audit of plant promoter target robustness, coupled to verified historical parser effects and separated target snapshots. Searches did not locate that applied result; novelty remains provisional pending expert review.

Limitations

Computational thinning only probes read-sampling depth, not transfection noise or between-library reproducibility. Fixed observed counts are not biological ground truth.

Decision and next step

Completed full execution as study 014, using all twelve model-relevant libraries and six replicate pairs; the result supports a computational resource note, with provisional novelty and explicit limits.

Observed results

Evidence and outputs

Sources and closest prior work

Exact literature search queries
  • "MPRA" "filtering" "RNA" "bias" threshold
  • "Jores" "downsampling" promoter
  • "STARR-seq" "barcode" "censoring"
  • "promoter" "sequencing depth" "median" barcode
  • "Jores" "RNA" "filtering" "bias"
  • "Jores" "sequencing depth" promoter
  • "plant" "promoter" "barcode" "downsampling"
  • "MPRA" "RNA" "filtering" "censoring"
  • "MPRAsnakeflow" "downsampling"
  • "Jores" "mpralm"
ATTEMPT 013

Did historical fixed-width count parsing alter inherited plant promoter labels?

Verified archive discrepancy — correctly parsed values already public

Question

Did the original readr fixed-width parser truncate high barcode counts, and are the resulting altered promoter values present in later plant-model benchmarks?

Why it might matter

Exact reconstruction exposed a deterministic discrepancy: 1137→137 for one RNA count reproduces an archived promoter value. The old parser inferred field boundaries from the first 1000 rows. This can be tested against the full raw files and archived downstream artifacts.

Minimal test

Compare robust whitespace count parsing to the fixed-width boundaries inferred from the first 1000 rows, using the original readr v1.4.0 source as reference. Confirm that all initially mismatched Arabidopsis values are reproduced without per-gene fitting; use maize libraries as negative controls.

First novelty check

The generic readr fixed-width limitation is documented. Novelty would be a previously unreported, verified impact on this experimental resource and its downstream model targets, with explicit corrected records. No claim of a new parser bug or broad invalidity of the biological study.

Larger test / frozen decision gates

Before scope outcomes: audit every native-promoter leaf/protoplast count file from the pinned source repository, infer widths from file layout rather than selecting moduli from outcomes, reconstruct all deposited per-replicate values with legacy-compatible parsing, and compute corrected labels with whitespace parsing. Verify inherited values in PGB splits and original CNN inputs. Quantify affected records, practical size, training/test membership and model-metric consequences. Create an executable historical-R reproduction or clearly delimit any remaining emulator uncertainty. Recheck closest prior work after results.

Second novelty check

The original repository has one public issue, requesting replicate data, whose author response supplies the correctly parsed measurements in 2023. PGB discussions concern unrelated viewer/gene-expression labels. A newly described discrepancy between snapshots may be useful provenance documentation, but producing the corrected values does not satisfy novelty on its own.

Limitations

Exact downstream agreement strongly supports the parser explanation but is not a record of the authors’ actual execution environment. A small number of changed labels may have negligible aggregate model impact; do not inflate severity.

Decision and next step

Close as a standalone discovery claim: retain the verified provenance audit and attachment comparison as support for the measurement-robustness study. Do not report PGB parser corruption or claim first correction of the source values.

Observed results

Evidence and outputs

Sources and closest prior work

Exact literature search queries
  • readr read_table truncates first digit counts fixed width
  • read_table readr digits cut off leading whitespace bug
  • "Jores" "read_table"
  • "Jores" "readr" truncation
  • "plant genomic benchmark" "parsing"
  • "promoter" "read_table" "bug"
  • "Jores" "promoter" "labels" benchmark discrepancy
  • "Synthetic promoter" "readr"
  • "plant genomic benchmark" promoter preprocessing Jores
ATTEMPT 014

Completed study: RNA-count filtering destabilizes plant promoter ranks

Executed — figures, data, reproducible workflow and research note

Question

Does the validated depth effect persist across all three promoter-origin species and both assay hosts, and does it affect evaluation of frozen published predictions?

Why it might matter

This executes the lead from 012. The applied contribution is measured resource-specific robustness, not a new estimator or biological regulatory mechanism.

Minimal test

See 012 for pilot and validation gates. No new thresholds were selected for this extension.

First novelty check

Pooling, MPRA downsampling and processing-bias studies precede this work. Targeted searches found no report of the exact Jores-resource comparison. The original author already supplied correct original-estimator values in 2023, so the parser correction is excluded from novelty.

Larger test / frozen decision gates

The extension protocol recorded under 012 was executed unchanged for Sb leaf replicates and all six protoplast libraries. Five seeds at 50%/25% RNA depth; DNA cutoffs 5/20; all four estimator variants, shared cohorts and dropout. Frozen CNN test predictions were mapped only where species/target matches uniquely identified a gene.

Second novelty check

Reviewed mpralm (2019), MPRAsnakeflow (2025), human MPRA processing comparisons (2025), the source study and its full public issue history, plus PGB discussions and targeted Jores/promoter/filtering/downsampling searches. No exact prior applied result found. Novelty remains provisional until expert review; no guarantee of publication.

Limitations

One experimental resource; two biological replicates per library/host combination; RNA-only thinning; high-coverage selected cohorts; pooled weighting is not proven biological truth; frozen-CNN subset evaluation; unresolved CNN-export provenance. Monte Carlo seeds are not biological replication.

Decision and next step

The local computational study is executed and yields a useful original empirical result under the searched literature scope. Package it for review as a short computational resource/methods note. Do not submit or contact authors without user instruction.

Observed results

Evidence and outputs

Sources and closest prior work

Exact literature search queries
  • "plant promoter" "RNA filtering" sequencing
  • "Jores" "barcode" "pooling"
  • "plant promoter" "downsampling" "median"
  • "Jores" "replicate" "reanalysis"
  • "Jores" "promoter" "correction" data counts
  • "Synthetic promoter designs" "error" data
ATTEMPT 015

Can automated bird detection manufacture apparent avoidance between species?

Closed — insufficient isolated, detectable source events

Question

If the occurrence of two bird vocalizations is experimentally independent, does a fixed-window audio classifier create a negative association between their detections, including when their calls do not overlap in time?

Why it might matter

Species co-occurrence and temporal partitioning are ecological quantities. Dependence of one species detection on another species vocalizing could manufacture evidence of competition or avoidance. A controlled mixture establishes presence without requiring inferred field interactions.

Minimal test

Select a fixed, deterministic sample of annotated short single-species events from the cached CEB test recordings, with no other annotated bird in the source excerpt. Require baseline target scores >=0.5 and use at most two excerpts per species from distinct source files. Combine pairs at matched event RMS, with simultaneous and non-overlapping event timing and matched attenuation controls. No clipping; hold baseline gain and placement explicit. Primary advancement gate: in non-overlapping mixtures at least 20% of baseline-detectable target appearances fall below 0.5, across at least four source species and two distinct recording pairs per affected species. Also report continuous score changes, simultaneous-mixture results and failed eligibility. Pilot file selection must not be reused as held-out validation.

First novelty check

Candidate generation found broad prior work on soundscape interference and synthetic multi-species mixing. The specific novelty question, after the minimal test, is whether controlled independent vocalizations produce spurious ecological association even without acoustic event overlap, and whether an explicit calibration can correct it.

Limitations

Annotation-based isolation does not guarantee absence of every unannotated sound. Audio mixing is an intervention on detectability, not evidence of real interactions among wild birds.

Decision and next step

Close this dataset-specific pilot without relaxing selection or confidence gates. Continue to another biological question.

Observed results

Evidence and outputs

Sources and closest prior work

Exact literature search queries
  • bird vocalization classifier synthetic mixtures co-occurrence bias
  • bird bioacoustics classifier mixed species false positive co occurrence networks BirdNET
ATTEMPT 016

Does strand-specific G-rich promoter architecture predict host portability?

Closed — predeclared motif-carrier gate failed

Question

Do canonical G-quadruplex-like promoter motifs show a strand-specific association with changes in activity between tobacco leaves and maize protoplasts, after accounting for ordinary sequence composition?

Why it might matter

A sequence feature associated with host portability could help design promoters that transfer between assay systems. G-rich secondary-structure motifs are plausible regulatory features, but their apparent effects can simply reflect GC or ordinary transcription-factor motifs. The pilot tests a narrow residual association and does not presume DNA folding.

Minimal test

Use maize-origin native promoter sequences and paired host activity estimates, requiring >=10 DNA-supported barcodes in both biological replicates of both hosts. Scan a fixed canonical G3 motif (four runs of >=3 G separated by 1–7 bases) and its reverse-complement C-rich counterpart. Before outcome testing require >=50 promoters for each orientation. Fit log2(leaf activity)-log2(protoplast activity) on motif indicators, mononucleotide and dinucleotide composition, regional GC content, quadratic/cubic overall GC and a canonical core TATA indicator. Primary contrast: G-motif coefficient minus C-motif coefficient; advance only if absolute contrast >=0.25 log2 and HC3 robust |t|>=3, with consistent sign using both original-median and pooled activity estimates. Hold sorghum and Arabidopsis outcomes out of this pilot.

First novelty check

Plant G4 sequence surveys and regulatory mechanisms already exist. A new contribution would require a specific, reproducible host-portability relationship that survives composition controls and independent validation, not simply enrichment of G-rich sequence in promoters.

Limitations

Motif matching does not demonstrate G4 formation, and transient reporter assays are not native genomic expression. This is exploratory mechanistic prioritization until replicated and independently validated.

Decision and next step

Close without lowering the minimum carrier count or inspecting outcome contrasts. Continue discovery.

Observed results

Evidence and outputs

Sources and closest prior work

Exact literature search queries
  • plant core promoter G quadruplex Jores promoter strength
ATTEMPT 017

Are the two ends of a plant gene functionally coordinated?

Closed — no meaningful coordination in the pilot

Question

Do separately measured native core-promoter and terminator activities covary for the same gene beyond shared sequence composition, and is this relationship consistent across assay hosts?

Why it might matter

A natural gene pairs its promoter and terminator, but synthetic designs often choose these parts independently. A reproducible residual association could test proposed coordination between transcription initiation and termination; it would not establish that a particular pair physically interacts.

Minimal test

Pilot only Arabidopsis chromosome 1 genes. Join native 170-base terminator activities from Gorjifard et al. 2024 to the 2021 promoter sequences and original-median / pooled promoter estimates, requiring >=10 DNA-supported promoter barcodes in both replicates of both hosts. Use gene-level averages when there are multiple terminator entries. Compute Spearman correlation and partial rank correlation after adjusting both activities for mono- and dinucleotide composition of both promoter and terminator, regional GC and overall GC squared/cubed. Advance only with >=500 matched genes and a positive partial correlation >=0.15 in both hosts using both promoter estimators. Hold other Arabidopsis chromosomes and maize out of this pilot.

First novelty check

Gene harmony is a prior hypothesis. An author dissertation also compares promoter, terminator and enhancer strengths with gene expression; this is a potential direct overlap to inspect before advancing. Merely joining two tables is not novel.

Limitations

Different reporter assays measure each end independently; these data cannot establish promoter–terminator interaction or causal evolutionary coadaptation. Chromosomes are partitions, not independent species.

Decision and next step

The frozen effect gate failed. Do not inspect held-out chromosomes or maize for this hypothesis.

Observed results

Evidence and outputs

Sources and closest prior work

Exact literature search queries
  • plant promoters terminators strengths same gene correlation Jores terminators 2022
  • "Arabidopsis and maize terminator strength" "promoter" correlation
ATTEMPT 018

Bird co-detection bias using single-species passages

Validation effect replicated; diversity gate failed

Question

Can two separately detectable bird vocalizations suppress one another in an automated detector even when they occupy disjoint parts of its input window?

Why it might matter

Entry 015 required exactly one annotation per excerpt. That excludes a bird producing several notes, although the excerpt can still contain only one species. This follow-up changes source eligibility to single-species passages and retains the original causal comparison and score/effect gates.

Minimal test

Use only the entry-015 pilot recording partition (SHA256 of 015:20260919:filepath, first 8 hex digits modulo 3 equals 0), keeping the other recordings uninspected for validation. For each annotated event center, take 1.2 seconds and require every intersecting valid annotation to belong to the target species, allowing multiple same-species events and excerpts of longer vocalizations. Select at most 8 candidate passages per species from distinct files, and 240 total, deterministically before model scores. Scale excerpts to a common RMS with a single clipping-safe scale. Require target score >=0.5 at both time positions, at least two source files per species; retain at most two passages per species. Compare exact-component baselines to non-overlapping mixtures in both orders and simultaneous mixtures. Advance if >=20% of non-overlapping target appearances lose detection at 0.5, across >=4 species with >=2 distinct recording pairs per affected species. The baseline and advancement thresholds are unchanged from entry 015.

First novelty check

Noise and soundscape interference are known. If the pilot succeeds, investigate prior demonstrations of spurious ecological association from temporal-context competition, and existing mitigations, before validating.

Limitations

Single-species annotation does not prove acoustic purity. Model conditioning on an eligible detectable subset limits population generalization; any result describes this controlled counterfactual experiment.

Decision and next step

Do not call this a completed study. Record the shortfall and pursue a separately specified focal-recording extension (entry019), retaining the existing negative feasibility outcomes.

Observed results

Evidence and outputs

Sources and closest prior work

Exact literature search queries
  • "BirdNET" "co-occurrence" bias mixtures
ATTEMPT 019

Independent focal-recording extension of the bird mixture experiment

Larger test and robustness controls passed; completed study in entry 020

Question

Does the disjoint-time detection loss reproduce with adequate species coverage in separately sourced focal recordings?

Why it might matter

The entry018 held-out effect replicated but its eight-species diversity gate failed. A separately specified source dataset can test transfer beyond the four eligible soundscape species without relaxing the score or loss thresholds. This is an extension of the same hypothesis, not an unrelated discovery.

Minimal test

Use the pinned CEB train_xenocanto recordings, independently annotated from the soundscape test recordings. For every target event, require all annotations intersecting a centered 1.2-second passage to be the target species, including blocking unknown-species annotations. Exclude passages starting before zero or extending beyond the actual recording. Before model outcomes, retain at most12 distinct-recording candidates/species and360 candidates total using SHA256 rank 019:20260919:event_id. Require target >=0.5 at both positions. Keep up to4 eligible clips/species with at least3 distinct files and at most16 species by fixed hash. Minimal eligibility gate: >=8 species,>=24 clips. Mixture effect gate unchanged: >=20% losses in nonoverlap at0.5,>=4 species affected in>=2 independent recording pairs. No further selection expansion after outcomes.

First novelty check

Entry018 first novelty review applies to the same narrow claim; additional literature review required after this source extension. Synthetic mixing, source separation and environmental interference are known.

Second novelty check

A second review after the focal result found no directly equivalent combination of disjoint-time counterfactuals, matched normalization and independent-presence association enumeration. General interference, source separation and detection-aware ecological models are prior work. Novelty remains provisional.

Limitations

Focal Xeno-Canto clips may have appeared in BirdNET training; this is not an unseen-classification-accuracy benchmark. The manipulated counterfactual remains defined, but ecological prevalence and field interaction claims are excluded. Recordists and per-file licenses must be retained.

Decision and next step

The frozen source-diversity and effect gates passed. Controls and the secondary natural-window check are executed; the complete note, limitations and reproducibility verification are recorded in entry 020.

Observed results

Evidence and outputs

Sources and closest prior work

Exact literature search queries
ATTEMPT 020

Completed study 02: disjoint-time interference in bird detections

Completed — executed and reproduced; novelty provisional

Question

Can an otherwise recognizable bird passage lose detection because another species calls elsewhere within the same three-second window, and can that generate an artificial negative co-detection association?

Why it might matter

This tests a specific failure of the observation process that could mislead short-window bird-interaction analyses. The outcome is a version-specific, reproducible stress test, not a new ecological mechanism or a new classifier.

Minimal test

Entry 018 produced 18 passages from nine species and more than 50% loss in both non-overlapping orders. Entry 015 had failed isolated-note eligibility. The separately held-out soundscape test replicated the effect but failed its frozen diversity gate; that failure remains explicit.

First novelty check

First review covered soundscape interference, overlapping mixtures, source separation, multi-label learning and imperfect detection. These broad ideas are established and are not claimed as new.

Larger test / frozen decision gates

Entry 019 prospectively specified a separate CEB focal-recording source. A fixed 360-candidate screen yielded 56 eligible passages, 56 files and 16 species, passing the source-diversity gate. Both orders, simultaneous mixtures, same-species mixtures, common-normalization intervention, continuous ambient controls and exact four-state presence enumeration were executed. A later, prospectively specified secondary check evaluated 364 natural field windows.

Second novelty check

The second documented review, followed by final title and software-discussion checks, found no directly equivalent empirical combination of disjoint-time bird mixtures, identical target components, controlled normalization and explicit independent-presence association. This supports a plausible original contribution; it is not proof of first-ever priority or journal acceptance.

Limitations

One pinned BirdNET v2.4 model, a selected European species set and a fixed primary threshold. Conditioning on detectability limits generalization. Xeno-Canto inputs may overlap training. Natural context removal also removes background, and reuses the soundscape dataset. No claim of real bird avoidance, wild-population error prevalence, validity of a deployable correction or failure of all occupancy studies. Novelty needs expert scrutiny.

Decision and next step

The second study is complete, reproduced, publicly readable, committed and pushed. The user-requested Telegram completion notification was delivered successfully. Stop this discovery loop on the executed, useful result; novelty remains provisional pending expert review. No manuscript was submitted and no author was contacted.

Observed results

Evidence and outputs

Sources and closest prior work

Exact literature search queries
  • "BirdNET" "disjoint" calls
  • "bird" "non-overlapping" "false negatives"
  • "bird" "temporal context" "suppression" classifier
  • "CEB" "Central European Birds" classification mixtures
  • bird acoustic classifier nonoverlapping vocalizations false negatives context pooling
  • "BirdNET" "independent" "co-occurrence" detection
  • "sound event detection" "context bias"
ATTEMPT 021

Can five retained transcribed bases introduce a reporter start-codon effect?

Closed — cross-host effect gate failed

Question

Do ATG start codons within the five native bases retained after the annotated transcription start predict reduced reporter RNA enrichment beyond ordinary promoter sequence composition?

Why it might matter

The 2021 plant core-promoter assay uses positions -165 to +5, followed by a common histone 5-prime UTR. The authors deliberately excluded longer native UTRs because they can affect RNA post-transcriptionally. A residual ATG in the retained five bases could potentially open a competing reading frame in the common reporter context. This is a hypothesis about an assay-specific sequence effect, not a claim of a new translation mechanism.

Minimal test

Use Arabidopsis chromosome 1 only, native promoters present in both assay hosts and both replicates, with at least 10 DNA-eligible barcodes per measurement at the established DNA cutoff 5. Require at least 50 last-five-base ATG carriers and at least 500 total promoters. Model log2 enrichment separately in leaf and maize protoplast, using sequence composition, GC polynomial, positional GC, a fixed TATA indicator and mono-nucleotide identity at the five retained bases. The ATG indicator tests a sequence interaction beyond these single-base terms; also report an upstream ATG count in the 30 bases before the retained segment. Test both the retained-median and pooled-count estimators. Advance only if all four ATG effects are <= -0.5 log2 units with HC3 |t| >=3. Do not inspect other chromosomes or promoter species for outcomes unless this gate passes.

First novelty check

After the minimal test, review upstream-ORF and reporter-assay work plus reuse of this exact dataset. Upstream translation and effects of native UTRs are already established. Source-method inspection is required to determine whether an ATG could be transcribed in the actual construct.

Limitations

Annotated TSSs are not measured reporter initiation sites. A terminal-ATG association might reflect initiator sequence preferences rather than translation, and cannot establish a uORF mechanism without independent evidence. This is an intentionally stringent feasibility/effect pilot.

Decision and next step

Frozen effect gate failed; do not examine validation chromosomes or species.

Observed results

Evidence and outputs

Sources and closest prior work

Exact literature search queries
  • Jores 2021 plant core promoters upstream AUG reporter transcription start site STARR seq 170 30
  • plant core promoter MPRA upstream open reading frame ATG confounding reporter RNA
ATTEMPT 022

Do cryptic splice-donor motifs predict post-transcriptional loss in intronic reporters?

Closed — paired-RNA effect gate failed

Question

In a plant MPRA where all fragments are placed inside a reporter intron, do strong sense-strand splice-donor motifs predict lower total-versus-newly-labeled RNA abundance than reverse-complement motifs?

Why it might matter

Voichek et al. 2024 measured both total mRNA and mRNA labeled during a 20-minute 5-EU pulse for the same approximately 12,000 reporter fragments. Correct splicing removes each variable insert, making fragment-dependent post-transcriptional differences an interesting possibility. An internal GT[AG]AGT donor could compete with the canonical donor; its reverse-complement sequence is a specificity control. Splicing effects are established biology, and the proposed assay mechanism requires independent support.

Minimal test

Use only Arabidopsis chromosome-1 origin fragments from Supplementary Table 5, including all three native positions, with finite paired total/5-EU values and exactly 160 A/C/G/T bases. Primary outcome is the published total-RNA minus newly-labeled-RNA log2 value. Regress on sense donor count GT[AG]AGT and reverse-complement count ACT[CT]AC, mono/dinucleotide composition, GC squared/cubed, fixed origin-position categories, and the known YVGATCBR regulatory motif count. Report the sense-minus-antisense coefficient contrast with standard errors clustered by source gene; a gene-cluster bootstrap will be used in validation if needed. Require >=500 fragments, >=50 sense-motif carriers and >=50 reverse-motif carriers; advance only for contrast <=-0.30 log2 and t<=-3. Other chromosomes and other MPRA outcomes remain unexamined until this gate passes.

First novelty check

After a passing pilot, search for cryptic-splicing effects in plant reporter libraries, previous reanalysis of this dataset and transcriptome evidence for insert retention. Known intron-mediated transcription enhancement and GATC effects are not new.

Limitations

A total/newly-labeled ratio is not a calibrated RNA half-life. The short labeling pulse, capture efficiency and transient expression may matter. A motif association does not prove altered splicing; follow-up RNA sequencing would be needed to support that mechanism.

Decision and next step

Frozen contrast gate failed; retain the negative result and leave validation chromosomes unexamined.

Observed results

Evidence and outputs

Sources and closest prior work

Exact literature search queries
  • "Widespread position-dependent transcriptional regulatory sequences in plants" data github
  • "Widespread position-dependent" splicing motifs intron
ATTEMPT 023

Does crowding GATC motifs reduce the benefit of an added copy?

Closed — crowding penalty contradicted by exploratory pilot

Question

Does a newly engineered GATC motif confer less incremental activity when its start is within 16 bases of another intact motif?

Why it might matter

The source study established copy-number enhancement and saturation. A residual spacing penalty would be a distinct constraint on engineering regulatory sequences. Sequential motif replacements allow comparison of one additional motif against the immediately preceding construct within each native fragment.

Minimal test

Use only chromosome-1 parent fragments in Supplementary Table 4. Reconstruct each step from exact sequence and its immediately preceding step, using Table 3 native sequences for step zero. Include only length-160 replacements yielding exactly one new YVGATCBR motif without losing any existing motif; require at least one pre-existing motif. Primary predictor: new motif start within 16 bp of the nearest existing motif. Outcome: current-minus-previous published log2 expression, separately for 35S and pTRP1. Regress on crowding, parent fixed effects, addition-step fixed effects, change in GC count and new motif position/160. Cluster uncertainty by parent. Require >=40 parents, >=120 eligible steps and >=25 crowded and uncrowded steps. Advance only for both crowding coefficients <=-0.15 log2 units and cluster t<=-3. Validation parents on other chromosomes remain unexamined.

First novelty check

The source already establishes GATC activity, motif-copy saturation and several other active sequences. Plant spacing effects in general and tandem GATC recognition in fungi are prior work. If the pilot passes, search specifically for plant intronic GATC spacing constraints and reanalyses of these engineered trajectories.

Limitations

Sequential motif replacements alter native bases as well as introduce the motif. Spacing is not experimentally isolated; an association would require held-out validation and controls for overwritten sequence and copy-number saturation. Shared adjacent measurements make steps correlated, hence parent-level inference.

Decision and next step

Reject the predeclared penalty hypothesis. An opposite-direction association motivates a separately labeled exploratory follow-up, not a successful original prediction.

Observed results

Evidence and outputs

Sources and closest prior work

Exact literature search queries
  • "Voichek" "epistasis" intron promoter
  • "GATC" "spacing" "motif" enhancement
  • "Widespread position-dependent transcriptional" "reanalysis"
ATTEMPT 024

Exploratory reversal: do neighboring GATC copies confer a larger incremental gain?

Executed — held-out synthetic-addition association; novelty provisional

Question

Does the opposite spacing association observed in entry 023 replicate on untouched parent fragments and survive sequence and saturation controls?

Why it might matter

Entry 023 predicted interference but observed +0.136/+0.159 log2 close-copy coefficients in 35S/pTRP1. This is explicitly a hypothesis generated after seeing pilot results. Cooperative motif action is established biology; only a replicated, quantitatively useful GATC spacing association in these intronic constructs could be a new contribution.

Minimal test

Exploratory signal inherited transparently from failed entry 023. The complete chromosome-1 pilot remains exploratory, with no confirmatory p-value claims.

First novelty check

First review found established plant enhancer cooperativity and spacing (Jores et al. 2024), intron-derived motif enhancement (Gallegos and Rose 2019), and tandem GATC sites 10–30 bp apart in fungal WCC binding (2015). Voichek et al. 2024 establish count effects and baseline saturation but no explicit nearest-neighbor effect in the paper or supplement. Broad intronic motif spacing was also proposed in a 2007 patent. This review supports only provisional novelty of the exact quantitative reanalysis, not a new general mechanism. A second review is mandatory after validation.

Larger test / frozen decision gates

Primary confirmation uses only parents from Arabidopsis chromosomes 2–5 in the same source tables, never inspected for this outcome. Reuse exactly the 023 sequence eligibility, nearest-start distance <=16 bp indicator, paired log2 increment and regression with parent and addition-step fixed effects, GC-count change and motif position. Require >=100 parents, >=600 steps and >=100 observations in each spacing group. Pass only if both backbone coefficients >=0.10 log2 and parent-cluster t>=3. No alternate threshold can rescue a failed primary gate.

Second novelty check

Reviewed the source supplement and mutation notebook; searched exact spacing and motif terms; screened 45 Europe PMC citing records and examined the closest 2026 positional-regulation papers. Known GATC dose effects, plant enhancer cooperation, fungal tandem GATC recognition and broad intronic spacing proposals are explicitly credited. No earlier report of this exact paired-step, held-out estimate was identified. Novelty remains provisional; the review records an inaccessible thesis hit and indexing limits.

Limitations

The library was designed for copy-number manipulation, with a minimum 2-bp edge gap, not a randomized spacing factorial. A spacing association cannot establish physical TF cooperativity. Outcomes are source-study replicate aggregates; independent parents, not individual steps, are the replication unit.

Decision and next step

The narrow computational study is executed, reproduced and packaged. The addition association survived its frozen holdout and controls; native-removal generalization was not established. External review is required before publication or broad design claims.

Observed results

Evidence and outputs

Sources and closest prior work

Exact literature search queries
  • "GATC" "cooperativity" plant intron
  • "GATC" "spacing" "Voichek"
  • "GATC" "distance" "Gallegos" motif
  • "intron-mediated enhancement" "motif" "spacing"
ATTEMPT 025

Round 3 completed: study, reproduction and preservation

Completed — study published locally, reproduced, Telegram sent

Question

Was the validated result fully executed, made reviewable and preserved alongside both earlier studies?

Why it might matter

A passing pilot alone does not complete the discovery loop. Completion requires larger validation, repeated novelty review, controls, a readable note and a portable, checked workflow.

Minimal test

The frozen chromosome holdout and parent/source-gene inference passed. Three earlier hypotheses in this round were retained as failures; the final hypothesis arose transparently from the opposite direction of the third pilot.

First novelty check

Provisional resource-specific novelty only; no claim of a new general motif mechanism or guaranteed publication.

Limitations

The native-motif loss check was inconclusive. The estimate applies to the synthetic addition library and requires a controlled spacing experiment for causal interpretation.

Decision and next step

Round 3 completed within the user’s stopping rule: a valuable, provisionally novel computational result was executed, reproduced and made reviewable. The authorized Telegram notification was confirmed. No manuscript submission or author contact was performed.

Observed results

Evidence and outputs

Sources and closest prior work

Exact literature search queries
ATTEMPT 026

Does yesterday’s cold alter today’s incubation investment?

Closed — close prior biological result

Question

Does prior-day temperature predict incubation attendance after accounting for current weather in hooded warblers?

Why it might matter

Repeated nest-day records could distinguish immediate weather responses from an energetic carry-over.

Minimal test

Downloaded the 2025 source workbook through the public version archive and inspected fields and replication; no outcome regression run.

First novelty check

Cartar & Montgomerie (1987) explicitly tested previous and concurrent weather; a 2020 multi-species sandpiper study reported the proposed effect and energetic interpretation.

Decision and next step

Reject as an original discovery lead. A further species-specific replication alone would not meet the current ambition.

Observed results

Evidence and outputs

Sources and closest prior work

Exact literature search queries
  • bird incubation "previous day" temperature attentiveness
  • "incubation" "carry-over" cold females
ATTEMPT 027

Heat and synchronized visits to water in wild zebra finches

Closed — predicted direction failed

Question

Do high temperatures increase five-minute co-visitation clustering at zebra finch water troughs beyond the opportunity caused by more visits?

Why it might matter

Heat raises individual drinking demand. The open RFID records can test whether resource co-use also becomes more clustered after accounting for visit opportunity.

Minimal test

Only dates 2017-12-16 through 2017-12-31. Other dates remain unanalysed for this outcome. Observed sum over bins choose(distinct birds,2), divided by expected pair co-visits under independent uniform placement within the twelve five-minute bins of an hour, preserving each bird’s hourly number of occupied bins. Use log((observed+0.5)/(expected+0.5)).

First novelty check

Funghi et al. 2019 found fewer birds foraging together in heat. Tyson et al. 2026 investigated wind and temperature in social networks at only 9–28C and did not establish a temperature association. Novelty of a water-specific high-temperature result remains unassessed.

Limitations

Five-minute co-visits are not direct observations of flock membership. Reader uptime is inferred from visits; temporal resolution and timezone need checks.

Decision and next step

Reject the increased-synchrony hypothesis. The opposite exploratory tendency is not a confirmed discovery; heat-related reductions in feeding-group size also have close prior work.

Observed results

Evidence and outputs

Sources and closest prior work

Exact literature search queries
  • "zebra finch" "water" "synchrony" heat
  • "zebra finch" water "social" heat visits data
ATTEMPT 028

Heat and switching between water sources

Closed — direction and date replication gates failed

Question

Do zebra finches reduce switching between water sources as days become hotter, even after accounting for the interval between visits?

Why it might matter

The two troughs are approximately 1 km apart. Increased drinking demand can reduce elapsed time between visits; test whether site switching falls beyond that time-budget effect. This concerns inter-water-source movement, distinct from the failed synchrony hypothesis.

Minimal test

December 2017 only. A feasibility count found 396 switches in 4,627 successive same-day visit pairs from 120 switching birds; no temperature relationship for switching was calculated before this protocol. Collapse bird/date/trough/five-minute duplicates. Sort visits within bird and date; retain successive visit gaps 30–360 minutes. Both visits must lie at least 10 minutes inside the intersection of observed first/last visit windows at BOTH troughs. Drop tied-time ambiguous trough records and pairs touching them. Use days with recorded MAX_TEMP and TO USE=1.

First novelty check

A broad heat effect on foraging movement is known. Whether this exact demand-adjusted water-switching question is new needs a focused review after the pilot.

Decision and next step

Reject. Both direction and minimum-date requirements failed; January–February switching outcomes remain unanalysed.

Observed results

Evidence and outputs

Sources and closest prior work

Exact literature search queries
ATTEMPT 029

Training reuse in a great tit developmental-clock assessment

Pilot passed — exclusion validation frozen

Question

Does reusing training samples materially alter the brood-treatment assessment of a great tit developmental methylation clock?

Why it might matter

The deposit and original analysis notebook permit exact sample matching and evaluation with the published clock coefficients.

Minimal test

Verified 34 overlapping samples among 102 deposited test samples; 33 remain among the 96 age-14 birds analyzed in the article. No predicted-age comparison has yet been run.

First novelty check

Provisional novelty only for an empirically quantified great-tit case and practical reanalysis, not for cross-validation, leakage, cross-fitting or the generic risk of reusing training samples. A second search after quantitative validation is required.

Larger test / frozen decision gates

For the same 33 age-14 training birds, their full-fit age predictions exceed predictions after exclusion of their individual and after exclusion of their known brood of origin by at least 0.5 days on average. For BOTH exclusion designs, mean paired (full-fit minus excluded) prediction among the 33 age-14 training birds >=0.5 day; 95% percentile origin-brood bootstrap interval of the paired mean excludes zero; at least 15 known origin-broods represented.

Limitations

Overlap alone does not establish that the treatment interpretation changes. The quantitative consequences must be tested; the title’s word Independent is not treated as a claim about the test samples.

Decision and next step

Proceed with the frozen same-bird exclusion tests and controls.

Observed results

Evidence and outputs

Sources and closest prior work

Exact literature search queries
  • "Haller" "epigenetic" "overlap" training
  • "Independent Avian Epigenetic Clocks" correction validation
  • "epigenetic age" "brood" "training" leakage
ATTEMPT 030

Great tit clock: matched exclusions pass the larger test

Validated result — preparing reproducibility package

Question

How much does fitting on a chick change the age measurement subsequently used in a brood-treatment analysis?

Minimal test

Entry 029 reproduced the exact published treatment model and identified 33 training birds among 96 age-14 test birds.

First novelty check

Provisionally original resource-specific reproducibility and sensitivity note: 33/96 treatment responses come from coefficient-fitting samples; matched exclusion shifts of 0.637/0.710 day, restored dispersion and fully disclosed treatment sensitivity. No exact prior reanalysis located. General overfitting, age shrinkage, cross-fitting and grouped validation are established and not novel contributions.

Larger test / frozen decision gates

Native glmnet reproduces every published coefficient within 1.1e-14. Exclude each individual, origin brood, rearing brood or cross-foster pair; compare the same 33 age-14 training birds. Protocol and a solver amendment were committed before exclusion outcomes.

Limitations

Fixed hyperparameters and shared candidate selection remain; this is conditional sensitivity of an existing estimator, not an unbiased new clock benchmark. The bootstrap conditions on fitted models; training membership was not randomized. The publication already reported proper leave-one-sample-out age accuracy.

Decision and next step

Proceed to complete reviewable note, figures, clean isolated rerun, archived package and preservation verification. Notify Telegram only on completion.

Observed results

Evidence and outputs

Sources and closest prior work

Exact literature search queries
  • "Independent Avian Epigenetic Clocks" "training" validation reuse
  • "Haller" "epigenetic" "brood" "bias"
  • "great tit" "clock" "cross-fitting"
  • "epigenetic clocks" "training" "treatment" "overfitting" birds
  • "14128" "epigenetic" correction
  • "great tit" "epigenetic" "sample overlap"
  • "epigenetic" "brood" "leave-one"
  • "Haller" "Risse" epigenetic "reanalysis"
  • "great tits" "epigenetic age" "training" "variance"
  • "14128" "correction" "clock"
  • "epigenetic" "brood" "overlap" training
ATTEMPT 031

Study 4 executed, reproduced and packaged

Completed — provisionally novel great tit reanalysis

Question

Does the measured case remain reproducible and useful after all planned checks?

First novelty check

Two focused reviews found no matching great-tit case analysis; general training reuse, grouped validation and cross-fitting have clear prior art. Novelty and publication suitability remain provisional.

Limitations

No independent biological cohort, no nested hyperparameter selection, no refutation of the original positive treatment direction. Bootstrap intervals condition on fitted models.

Decision and next step

Scientific study complete under the requested stopping rule. Finish public artifact checks, git push and the authorized completion-only Telegram notification. No submission or author contact.

Observed results

Evidence and outputs

Sources and closest prior work

Exact literature search queries
ATTEMPT 032

Round 4 complete; Telegram notification confirmed

Completed — delivered and preserved

Question

Is the completed study accessible and the requested completion ping sent?

Limitations

Training reuse and grouped validation are known methods; novelty concerns this empirical reanalysis. It does not refute the positive treatment direction or establish a new independently validated biological clock.

Decision and next step

Round 4 is complete under the requested stopping rule: an executed, reproducible and provisionally original great-tit case study with explicit limitations. No manuscript submission or author contact.

Observed results

Evidence and outputs

Sources and closest prior work

Exact literature search queries