{
  "created_utc": "2026-09-19T05:29:44.853501+00:00",
  "id": "024",
  "title": "Exploratory reversal: do neighboring GATC copies confer a larger incremental gain?",
  "status": "First novelty review passed provisionally; validation frozen",
  "question": "Does the opposite spacing association observed in entry 023 replicate on untouched parent fragments and survive sequence and saturation controls?",
  "rationale": "Entry 023 predicted interference but observed +0.136/+0.159 log2 close-copy coefficients in 35S/pTRP1. This is explicitly a hypothesis generated after seeing pilot results. Cooperative motif action is established biology; only a replicated, quantitatively useful GATC spacing association in these intronic constructs could be a new contribution.",
  "minimal_test": "Exploratory signal inherited transparently from failed entry 023. The complete chromosome-1 pilot remains exploratory, with no confirmatory p-value claims.",
  "larger_test": "Primary confirmation uses only parents from Arabidopsis chromosomes 2\u20135 in the same source tables, never inspected for this outcome. Reuse exactly the 023 sequence eligibility, nearest-start distance <=16 bp indicator, paired log2 increment and regression with parent and addition-step fixed effects, GC-count change and motif position. Require >=100 parents, >=600 steps and >=100 observations in each spacing group. Pass only if both backbone coefficients >=0.10 log2 and parent-cluster t>=3. No alternate threshold can rescue a failed primary gate.",
  "controls": [
    "If primary passes, repeat in parents with zero native consensus motifs, controlling addition step categorically.",
    "Add original fragment expression from independent MIX1 (Table 3, Arabidopsis downstream, same backbone) interacted with addition-step indicators, plus native motif count interacted with step. These address baseline-dependent saturation.",
    "Control overwritten 8-bp sequence mono/dinucleotide counts and number of changed bases, position squared/cubed and distance to fragment edge.",
    "Parent-cluster bootstrap (2000 resamples, fixed seed 240919); show leave-one-chromosome-out effects.",
    "Report spacing curves and alternative 12/20/24/32-bp thresholds as secondary sensitivity analyses only.",
    "Assess independent native multi-motif elimination designs where sufficient samples exist; report feasibility limits instead of inventing validation.",
    "Check exact synthesis coordinates, missing values, duplicate parents/source genes, and reproduce primary result via independent residualization implementation."
  ],
  "novelty": "First review found established plant enhancer cooperativity and spacing (Jores et al. 2024), intron-derived motif enhancement (Gallegos and Rose 2019), and tandem GATC sites 10\u201330 bp apart in fungal WCC binding (2015). Voichek et al. 2024 establish count effects and baseline saturation but no explicit nearest-neighbor effect in the paper or supplement. Broad intronic motif spacing was also proposed in a 2007 patent. This review supports only provisional novelty of the exact quantitative reanalysis, not a new general mechanism. A second review is mandatory after validation.",
  "limitations": "The library was designed for copy-number manipulation, with a minimum 2-bp edge gap, not a randomized spacing factorial. A spacing association cannot establish physical TF cooperativity. Outcomes are source-study replicate aggregates; independent parents, not individual steps, are the replication unit.",
  "decision": "Run the frozen held-out test. If it fails, close this lead. If it passes, perform all controls, second novelty review and full reproducible execution before claiming completion.",
  "sources": [
    {
      "title": "Voichek et al. 2024 source",
      "url": "https://doi.org/10.1038/s41588-024-01907-3"
    },
    {
      "title": "Jores et al. 2024 enhancer cooperativity",
      "url": "https://doi.org/10.1093/plcell/koae088"
    },
    {
      "title": "Gallegos and Rose 2019 intron motif",
      "url": "https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-019-50389-5"
    },
    {
      "title": "Neurospora tandem GATC binding",
      "url": "https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1005105"
    },
    {
      "title": "Prior broad intronic motif-spacing proposal",
      "url": "https://patents.google.com/patent/US20070204367A1/en"
    }
  ],
  "searches": [
    "\"GATC\" \"cooperativity\" plant intron",
    "\"GATC\" \"spacing\" \"Voichek\"",
    "\"GATC\" \"distance\" \"Gallegos\" motif",
    "\"intron-mediated enhancement\" \"motif\" \"spacing\""
  ],
  "artifacts": [
    {
      "title": "Frozen validation and control protocol",
      "path": "round-003/evidence/024_protocol.json"
    }
  ]
}
