{
  "reviewed_utc": "2026-09-19T05:39:30.581790+00:00",
  "claim_under_review": "A held-out, sequence-verified association between <=16-bp nearest-motif start distance and larger incremental expression gains from synthetic CAGATCTG additions to plant intronic reporter fragments.",
  "decision": "Provisional novelty supported for the narrow quantitative reanalysis. No claim that GATC activity, enhancer cooperativity, spacing effects generally, or the underlying molecular mechanism is new.",
  "queries": [
    "\"intronic\" \"GATC\" \"spacing\"",
    "\"GATC\" \"neighbor\" \"plant\"",
    "\"GATC\" \"spacing\" \"transcription\" \"plant\" -SeqA -coli -bacterial -replication -DamID",
    "\"Widespread position-dependent transcriptional regulatory sequences in plants\" \"2026\"",
    "\"Voichek\" \"GATC\" \"spacing\" -SeqA -replication",
    "\"CAGATCTG\" \"distance\"",
    "\"GATC\" \"cooperative\" Arabidopsis intron -SeqA -coli -Dam",
    "\"Upstream, downstream: nemo learns\"",
    "\"Positional grammar of transcription factor binding\" GATC spacing",
    "\"nemo\" \"GATC\" motif plant"
  ],
  "citation_screen": {
    "url": "https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/MED/39266765/citations?page=1&pageSize=100&format=json",
    "records_returned": 45,
    "scope": "Title screening of all returned records, followed by targeted reading of closest positional-regulation papers. This is not full-text review of all45 records; indexing coverage is incomplete.",
    "artifact": "024_citing_articles.json"
  },
  "nearest_prior_work": [
    {
      "doi": "10.1038/s41588-024-01907-3",
      "finding": "Voichek et al. 2024 measured the library and established GATC copy effects, baseline-dependent saturation and downstream position dependence. Main text, supplement, and archived mutation notebook reviewed. Their addition analysis groups by total motif gain rather than nearest-neighbor distance.",
      "difference": "Our contribution is paired adjacent-step spacing analysis with a chromosome holdout and nuisance controls, not discovery of this motif or library."
    },
    {
      "doi": "10.1093/plcell/koae088",
      "finding": "Jores et al. 2024 experimentally established plant enhancer cooperativity and effects of spacing/order among functional regions in three light-responsive enhancers.",
      "difference": "Strong general precedent; distinct upstream enhancer fragments and light response, not this intronic GATC addition-series estimate."
    },
    {
      "doi": "10.1038/s41598-019-50389-5",
      "finding": "Gallegos and Rose 2019 show TTNGATYTG motif dose effects and splicing-independent enhancement. Full XML reviewed.",
      "difference": "Motif dose and intron position already known; no matched nearest-copy spacing estimate found."
    },
    {
      "doi": "10.1371/journal.pgen.1005105",
      "finding": "Neurospora WCC binding sites have enriched tandem GATC spacings around10\u201330 bp.",
      "difference": "Direct biological precedent for tandem GATC organization, but fungal binding system; does not demonstrate plant reporter mechanism."
    },
    {
      "doi": "10.1046/j.1365-313X.2003.01899.x",
      "finding": "Sugimoto et al. 2003 show plant AGP binding and reporter activation using repeated AGATCCAA motifs; adenine methylation does not abolish binding.",
      "difference": "GATC recognition and tandem activity are old; no matching intronic paired-spacing test identified."
    },
    {
      "doi": "10.1093/plphys/kiag473",
      "finding": "Rockenbach et al. 2026 (nemo) predict motif effects as a function of TSS position. Full methods state insertion of individual motifs into separate contexts and focus on additive individual-motif effects.",
      "difference": "Does not assess nearest-neighbor motif interactions or the synthetic addition trajectories here."
    },
    {
      "doi": "10.1038/s41467-026-75947-0",
      "finding": "Morales-Cruz et al. 2026 integrate multiDAP binding, chromatin and expression to examine positional regulatory context and TF clusters.",
      "difference": "Genomic position/chromatin analysis rather than this intervention series."
    },
    {
      "url": "https://patents.google.com/patent/US20070204367A1/en",
      "finding": "A 2007 patent broadly proposes changing intronic motif copy number and spacing.",
      "difference": "Prevents a claim that the design concept is new. This study is an empirical resource-specific quantification, not a patentability opinion."
    }
  ],
  "limitations": [
    "An NC State thesis search hit discussed upstream synthetic-promoter spacing; full access returned a bot-check page, so it was not cleared through full-text inspection.",
    "Non-indexed work, inaccessible supplements and unpublished analyses may contain the same result. Expert review remains necessary.",
    "The independent native-motif removal check did not establish replication. A universal spacing rule or molecular cooperativity claim is unsupported."
  ]
}
