{
  "created_utc": "2026-09-19T06:33:32.354897+00:00",
  "stage": "Second review, after primary larger gate and numerical/cluster controls passed",
  "queries": [
    "\"Independent Avian Epigenetic Clocks\" \"training\" validation reuse",
    "\"Haller\" \"epigenetic\" \"brood\" \"bias\"",
    "\"great tit\" \"clock\" \"cross-fitting\"",
    "\"epigenetic clocks\" \"training\" \"treatment\" \"overfitting\" birds",
    "\"14128\" \"epigenetic\" correction",
    "\"great tit\" \"epigenetic\" \"sample overlap\"",
    "\"epigenetic\" \"brood\" \"leave-one\"",
    "\"Haller\" \"Risse\" epigenetic \"reanalysis\"",
    "\"great tits\" \"epigenetic age\" \"training\" \"variance\"",
    "\"14128\" \"correction\" \"clock\"",
    "\"epigenetic\" \"brood\" \"overlap\" training"
  ],
  "nearest_prior_work": [
    {
      "title": "Haller et al. 2025 and openly archived analysis notebook",
      "url": "https://doi.org/10.1111/1755-0998.14128",
      "inspected": "Full text XML, coefficient supplement, deposited data and rendered R notebook",
      "relation": "Original already reports leave-one-sample-out accuracy, developmental age shrinkage and the full-coefficient treatment analysis. The training reuse is visible in the data and code. Our contribution is specifically the matched 33-bird counterfactual effect on the mixed treatment response and family/pair exclusions; not first discovery of age shrinkage or an inaccurate claim that source reported training error as CV accuracy."
    },
    {
      "title": "Methods for analysing wildlife DNA methylation data (2026)",
      "url": "https://doi.org/10.1093/conphys/coaf091",
      "inspected": "Full text via Europe PMC",
      "relation": "Much broader dolphin reanalysis of training-population choices, age and health endpoints, residual calibration, and cross-fitting. Direct prior methodological framework. No Haller or great-tit case or 33-bird result located."
    },
    {
      "title": "An epigenetic clock for Xenopus tropicalis (2025)",
      "url": "https://doi.org/10.1038/s41514-025-00236-x",
      "inspected": "Publisher full methods/results",
      "relation": "Already compares individual and tank exclusions, randomized tank controls and independent sample preparation. Clear prior art for group-exclusion sensitivity, which is not claimed as new here."
    },
    {
      "title": "Sequencing method matters: differential performance of DNA methylation data acquisition in epigenetic clock calibration (2025)",
      "url": "https://doi.org/10.1002/jav.03498",
      "inspected": "Publisher full methods/results/discussion",
      "relation": "Chestnut-crowned babblers; includes leave-one-individual-out handling repeated samples and mentions Haller developmental clocks. No analysis of Haller training reuse or brood treatment data. Establishes avian individual-level validation precedent."
    },
    {
      "title": "Designing Epigenetic Clocks for Wildlife Research (2025)",
      "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12415925/",
      "inspected": "Prior review excerpts; PMC retrieval intermittently blocked",
      "relation": "Independent testing and sampling design are known. Credit explicitly."
    },
    {
      "title": "The BEAC, an epigenetic clock for birds (August 2026 preprint)",
      "url": "https://doi.org/10.64898/2026.08.14.744821",
      "inspected": "Abstract and indexed author-preprint methods/results excerpts; direct bioRxiv full-text retrieval failed",
      "relation": "King penguin independent validation and cross-species bird clock. No matching great-tit reuse analysis located. Limited access prevents exhaustive exclusion."
    }
  ],
  "conclusion": "Provisionally original resource-specific reproducibility and sensitivity note: 33/96 treatment responses come from coefficient-fitting samples; matched exclusion shifts of 0.637/0.710 day, restored dispersion and fully disclosed treatment sensitivity. No exact prior reanalysis located. General overfitting, age shrinkage, cross-fitting and grouped validation are established and not novel contributions.",
  "publication_scope": "Suitable for evaluation as a short computational reanalysis or methods case study with complete reproduction; neither acceptance nor priority guaranteed. No submission or author contact made.",
  "limitations": "Search indexing and accessible documents are incomplete. Europe PMC citation list omitted at least the Gerber paper found by broader search. No absence-of-results proof of novelty."
}
